The issues of the second amendment

Issue: Second Amendment

Are we talking about a state defending its freedom against neighboring states, against foreign states, against the United States? Many in the Founding generation believed that governments are prone to use soldiers to oppress the people.

Where Supreme Court nominee Brett Kavanaugh stands on key issues

Documentary History Historical context The 2nd Amendment, starting in the latter half of the 20th century, became an object of much debate.

Justice Samuel Alito, writing for the majority, was matter-of-fact in his conclusion: In opposition, the British forces consisted of a mixture of the standing British ArmyLoyalist militia and Hessian mercenaries. The need to have arms for self-defence was not really in question.

Two years later, in McDonald v. In opinions and speeches, Kavanaugh has questioned a ruling in a Supreme Court case, Chevron v. The traditional militia fell into desuetude, and state-based militia organizations were eventually incorporated into the federal military structure.

2nd Amendment Issues

If we decide to do away with the individual ownership aspect of the Amendment, reinterpreting the amendment to allow highly restricted gun ownership, we seem to open the door to radical reinterpretation of other, more basic parts of the Constitution.

Notwithstanding the lengthy opinions in Heller and McDonald, they technically ruled only that government may not ban the possession of handguns by civilians in their homes.

The Court, which found for Heller in a close decision, wrote that the 2nd Amendment did, in fact, protect an individual right.

Thus, any such protections would have to come from state law. Here is its full text: These soldiers, while part-time, are professionally trained and armed by the government.

Federalists argued that this government had an unworkable division of power between Congress and the states, which caused military weakness, as the standing army was reduced to as few as 80 men.

The Court finally noted that its ruling affected only the District of Columbia, as a federal enclave. The Court ruled that the Chicago regulations were unconstitutional, and that the rights previously found in the Heller case were individual rights that also applied to state and local governments.

In District of Columbia v. Why cannot gun ownership by similarly regulated without violating the Constitution?

The Second Amendment is a mess

Nixon, which set a key precedent limiting presidential claims of executive privilege. Differences exist between the drafted and ratified copies, the signed copies on display, and various published transcriptions.

In DecemberI led an effort in the U.The Second Amendment (Amendment II) to the United States Constitution protects the right of the people to keep and bear arms and was adopted on December 15, One of the issues the Bill resolved was the authority of the King to disarm his subjects.

A discussion of the Constitutional Topic of the Second Amendment. Second Amendment The 2nd Amendment to the U.S. Constitution reads: "A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed.".

The Second Amendment also raises issues about which reasonable people can disagree. But if the Supreme Court takes this provision of the Constitution as seriously as it now takes the First Amendment, which it should do, there will be some easy issues as well.

The Problem With The Second Amendment (And Democracy In General) The Second Amendment states: “A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed.”.

2nd Amendment Issues. As a firearm owner and a lifetime member of the NRA, I believe that our Second Amendment rights are fundamental and must be protected. I have been a proud supporter of pro-Second Amendment measures such as the National Right to Carry Reciprocity Act.

The issues of the second amendment
Rated 5/5 based on 68 review